Judge rules in favor of Kenmore in solar panel dispute with local man

A King County Superior Court judge on Aug. 16 ruled in favor of the city of Kenmore regarding a solar panel dispute with a local man.

Kenmore resident Patrick O’Brien in front of his solar panel structure

A King County Superior Court judge on Aug. 16 ruled in favor of the city of Kenmore regarding a solar panel dispute with a local man.

The city contended that Patrick O’Brien, who the city in January ordered to take down his solar panels in response to a citizen complaint, misrepresented his structure as an arbor for grape vines and failed to obtain a permit for the unsafe structure.

O’Brien, who is running for Kenmore City Council, filed a Land Use Petition Act (LUPA) appeal in February in King County Superior Court over the decision, claiming the issue is about local jurisdictions “taking control” of green energy.

He claimed the Hearing Examiner, which upheld the city’s decision, erred in its ruling because the city does not have an ordinance that deals with the use and installation of solar panels.

But Judge Catherine Shaffer ruled that the city was not preempted by state law from requiring a building permit for the structure and that city code requires a permit for all structures – including solar panels.

Shaffer also found that O’Brien did not establish that the building permit fee constituted a tax because the fees pay for the costs of processing permit applications.

Kenmore city officials say the city has accrued more than $40,000 in legal and Hearing Examiner costs to defend this case.

“This case has been very clear-cut from the beginning,” said Mayor David Baker in a press release. “It’s a shame that so many resources and tax dollars had to go toward enforcing obvious violations of the city’s safety codes.”

City Manager Rob Karlinsey added “the unambiguous and decisive decisions by both the Hearing Examiner and the superior court judge speak to the professionalism and integrity of my co-workers who are tasked with enforcing the city’s safety codes.

“As a city, we value and encourage solar panels — in fact, Kenmore City Hall has solar panels. We also put a high priority on safety. When forced to choose between solar panels and safety, we will always choose safety. Obtaining building permits for the structural installation of solar panels will help ensure their safety.”

O’Brien said he is disappointed with the judge’s decision.

“I was aghast,” he said. “It was a Friday afternoon and the judge said, ‘You’ve got 10 minutes.’ I didn’t spend all that time and money for weeks and weeks to be given 10 minutes.”

He agrees with Baker that the city wasted tax dollars on this case.

“They can gloat,” O’Brien said of city officials, “but the city has spent more than [$40,000] on this and if they think that’s what a good use of their time and money is, that’s the city manager’s call. Where the blame lays on that is the thing to be debated.”

O’Brien said he is also considering appealing the decision to the Court of Appeals.

“What I see in this is that I lost the battle but I didn’t lose the war and it will be up to others in the city of Kenmore to come forward when they feel they are being abused,” O’Brien said.

O’Brien has 30 days from Aug. 16 to appeal the decision.

During the appeal hearing, Shaffer also ruled on a separate code enforcement action over a retaining wall, noting that substantial evidence supports the city’s and Hearing Examiner’s determination that the wall is unsafe.


In consideration of how we voice our opinions in the modern world, we’ve closed comments on our websites. We value the opinions of our readers and we encourage you to keep the conversation going.

Please feel free to share your story tips by emailing editor@bothell-reporter.com.

To share your opinion for publication, submit a letter through our website https://www.bothell-reporter.com/submit-letter/. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. (We’ll only publish your name and hometown.) We reserve the right to edit letters, but if you keep yours to 300 words or less, we won’t ask you to shorten it.

More in News

Pexel Images
Two patients contracted COVID-19 while at EvergreenHealth in Kirkland

A press release from the hospital states it has contacted 100 employees that had various levels of exposure, and that the direct source in this case is unclear

Virtual town halls coming up for unincorporated King County

Events throughout September and October via Zoom will cater to different areas of the region.

Seven decades later, the search for two missing Navy pilots continues

The pilots are thought to have disappeared near Black Lake, northeast of North Bend.

A view of the Palmer Fire, located seven miles southwest of Oroville in north central Washington. Source: InciWeb
Antifa isn’t starting Washington wildfires

Online conspiracy theories are spreading as the West Coast burns.

The truck of the Renton family as it was found Tuesday. While fleeing the Cold Springs Fire two adults were severely burned and one toddler died. Courtesy photo/Okanogan Sheriff’s Office
Toddler killed as Renton family flees Cold Springs Fire

The parents were severely burned and are being treated at Harborview Medical Center

A plane drops fire retardant on the Palmer Mountain Fire last week. The fire is listed as 84 percent contained, and fully lined. Laura Knowlton/Sound Publishing staff photo
Threat multiplier: How climate change, coronavirus and weather are scorching WA

Dry summer conspired with the pandemic and a wind storm.

Screenshot from the state Employment Security Department’s website at esd.wa.gov.
Workers may qualify for an extra $1,500 in unemployment back pay

A federal program will give some of the state’s unemployed a $300 weekly bump for the past five weeks.

Screenshot of the air quality monitor at 11 a.m., Tuesday, Sept. 8. Courtesy Puget Sound Clean Air Agency.
King County faces unhealthy air quality due to wildfire smoke

Weather monitors recommend people limit time outdoors, especially children, seniors and those with heart or lung disease.

Image courtesy of the Washington Department of Natural Resources.
Massive wildfires incinerate WA

All state Department of Natural Resources lands were closed to recreational activities on Sept. 8.

Evergreen Academy Preschoolers make donations for Blueberry Gardens Senior Care. Courtesy photo/Evergreen Academy Preschool
Photos: preschoolers make homemade crafts for Bothell seniors

Students from Bothell Evergreen Academy Preschool are learning the value of spreading joy in the community

Pictured left to right: Former Congressman Dave Reichert, Slade Gorton, and King County Councilmember Reagan Dunn visit Washington, D.C., to testify in favor of the Mountains to Sound Greenway National Heritage Area designation. Courtesy photo
Former U.S. Sen. Slade Gorton dies at 92

Former U.S. Sen. Slade Gorton died Aug. 19 in Seattle at age… Continue reading

Highlighted in yellow box sits the Chaipatanapong property, where Kenmore hopes to place a new public works facility. Courtesy photo/City of Kenmore.
Kenmore family questions eminent domain case involving culturally significant property

Mayor David Baker said he is ‘disgusted by the accusations’ regarding warehouse acquisition.