Enforcing the law | Letter

Regarding Mr. Roegner’s piece “Are Sheriffs above the law?” (bothell-reporter.com, April 9), that article contained a particularly disturbing piece of doublespeak:

“Recently 13 elected county sheriffs said they will ignore…I-1639 because they didn’t think it was constitutional, which places them at odds with their sworn oath to uphold the law and the Constitution.”

I do not know if Mr. Roegner read this sentence before publishing, but it is absurd at face value. If a sheriff believes a law is unconstitutional, then the very essence of upholding an oath to protect the Constitution is to refuse to enforce such a law.

He later claims that law enforcement do not have discretion over which laws to enforce. This is false, strictly speaking from a legal perspective. Court rulings such as Town of Castle Rock v. Gonzales establish that police are not obligated to enforce any law. And there is a long American tradition of law enforcement refusing to enforce unjust and harmful laws such as imprisoning non-violent drug offenders, immigration (sanctuary cities), going clear back to refusal to enforce the Fugitive Slave Act. The common thread? A respect for the liberties of peaceful individuals in the face of a government being driven by special interests seeking oppression.

Mr. Roegner should be grateful to know there are local law enforcement officials willing to stand up for the rights of citizens in their communities, because when state or federal government turns bad, they are the last line of defense to protect Americans from tyranny short of citizens themselves rising up. The Second Amendment was written in recognition of this reality that the writers had just lived through.

David Johnson


More in Letters to the Editor

A historic and cultural gem | Letter

We were surprised and dismayed to learn that the Bus Rapid Transit… Continue reading

So important now | Letter

Sept. 1 marked 80 years since Hitler invaded Poland and started World… Continue reading

So important now | Letter

I certainly agree with Willie Dickerson (“Don’t just vote, speak up,” Reporter,… Continue reading

Trump’s message unseemly but not racist | Letter

Many of Ms. Pak’s columns revolve around a recurring theme: “Let’s talk… Continue reading

A heavy burden | Letter

There are more than 110,000 residents of our state living with Alzheimer’s… Continue reading

Vote ‘yes’ on Prop. 1 | Letters

Vote ‘yes’ to Prop. 1 Please vote to approve the revised Prop.… Continue reading

A climate crisis | Letter

A climate crisis Aaron Kunkler’s article on feedback loops of CO2 and… Continue reading

Use your voice | Letter

Excellent reporting on the Margins program from Mercer Island High School (Reporter,… Continue reading

Safe teen drivers | Letter

As school gets out for the summer, I’d like to stress the… Continue reading

Alternative to Sammamish River Trail | Letter

The proposed King County improvements to the Sammamish River Trail should be… Continue reading

In the hands of voters | Letter

Every voter in the state of Washington should be furious with the… Continue reading

A humanitarian crisis | Letter

Hundreds killed or injured. Many raped. Bodies found in the Nile. Sudan… Continue reading